Your health and well-being are our top priority…

facebook.png twitter.png linkedin.png pinterest.png youtube.png Instagram.png

Aronoff's Point Of View: CMS rating system is flawed

Category List

Tag List

Renal Center of Beaumont (1)
acute nurse (1)
The Hills (1)
Spirit Award (1)
Interview (1)
plasmapheresis (1)
halitosis (1)
peritoneal dialysis (3)
work anniversary (1)
Bone and Joint Expo (1)
Certified Registered Nurse Infusion (1)
cupcake (1)
Renal Center of Bayonne (1)
American Heart Association (6)
Stroke (2)
Costa Vida (1)
Rugged Maniac (1)
Dr. George Aronoff (4)
graduates (1)
American Nephrology Nurses' Association (1)
oral hygiene (1)
Renal Center of Plano (2)
Southeast flooding (1)
Renal Center of Morristown (1)
rheumatology (1)
back to school (1)
Pinnacle award (1)
kidney disease exercise (1)
Citizenship Day (3)
RVCare (4)
cookbook (2)
Heart Disease (2)
Social Worker (1)
dogs (1)
West Virginia (1)
Walk to Cure Arthritis (1)
Bonfils blood donation (2)
CMS (2)
American Society of Nephrology (1)
National MS Society (1)
Choose My Plate (1)
Informative Infuser (1)
Renal Center of Hamilton (3)
Dum Dums (1)
Infusion (6)
Orange, TX (1)
smoke alarm (1)
Dr. Stuart Kassan (1)
RV Difference (8)
American College of Rheumatology (1)
RV TLC (1)
bubble soccer (1)
acute dialysis (1)
Plano (1)
DaVita Healthcare partners (1)
Intern (3)
new dialysis facility (1)
North Texas Acute (1)
New Jersey (6)
Take Your Dog to Work Day (1)
RVMLife (1)
Renal Center of Passaic (1)
meningioma (1)
10th anniversary (3)
retirement (1)
open house (2)
Home Kidney Care (2)
Dr. Parker (1)
Naveena Reddy (1)
National Kidney Month (2)
Spring Clinical Meeting (1)
Renal Center of Orange (1)
Javier Rodriguez (1)
Children's Hospital (1)
Diane McGinnis (1)
ANNA conference (1)
DaVita (2)
JCAHO accreditation (1)
Kidney walk (1)
acquisition (1)
BioMed (1)
Fitibt (1)
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (1)
Blizzard 2016 (1)
immunization (2)
RV Quality Program (3)
Lobby Day (1)
Renal Center of North Denton (1)
home hemodialysis (1)
Pioneer award (1)
Renal Adventures (2)
Kidney Life Dialysis Center (1)
Z Constructors (1)
Renal Center of Succasunna (1)
Do's and Don'ts when interviewing (1)
Michelle Weinraub (1)
miss dialysis (2)
Renal Center of Port Arthur (1)
World Kidney Day (7)
Best Place to Work (3)
Five Star rating (1)
permanent access (1)
CRNI (1)
NKF (2)
Dallas (1)
Tracy Moore (1)
pot de creme (1)
Toledo Bend Reservoir (1)
40th anniversary (1)
remote patient monitoring (2)
Pinterest (1)
Patient Satisfaction Survey (1)
Council of Nephrology Social Workers (1)
gum disease (1)
Authentidate (2)
dialysis center (1)
National Kidney Foundation (5)
Port Arthur (1)
Savor the Flavor of Eating Right (1)
Fire Prevention Week (1)
dialysis patient exercise (1)
Kidney Week (1)
patient newsletter (3)
wrestling (1)
North Denton (1)
Paulding Phelps Award (1)
flu vaccine (3)
Renal Center of Somerville (3)
Human Resources (1)
Southlake, TX (1)
RV KidneyCARE (2)
QIRN3 (1)
apheresis (1)
Frosty the Snowman (1)
Redesign American Flag (1)
Internship (3)
recipe (2)
nephron (1)
Multiple Sclerosis Society (1)
Elanderia Rowe (1)
Accel Rehab hospital (1)
Glass of water (1)
Infusion nurse (2)
Digna Gutierrez (1)
dental care (1)
Dr. Aronoff (3)
Renal Center of Trenton (1)
Kidney cookbook (1)
flu shot (4)
Texas Renal Ventures (2)
Positively Protein (3)
Avalon at Edgewater (1)
New York Yankees (1)
CMS rating system (3)
Mary Bowles (1)
Kindergarten (1)
NKF walk (2)
RVM Kidney Care (1)
New Orleans (1)
traveling on dialysis (1)
Winter Storm Jonas (1)
Nephrology News (4)
Protein (2)
American Diabetes Association (1)
RASKAL award (3)
Employee Appreciation (1)
construction (2)
dialysis treatment (2)
Excellence award (1)
Arthritis Foundation (2)
Nederland (1)
RV Wellness (4)
Southlake Infusion (1)
Tuition reimbursement (3)
Naveena Redd (2)
Year in Review (5)
World Kidney Month (4)
NRAA (2)
Annual Dialysis Conference (1)
travel (1)
telehealth services (1)
Denton police department (1)
video (1)
Mother's Day (1)
Renal Center of Carrollton (1)
dialysis (2)
Orange (1)
World Health Day (1)
ANNA (1)
Officer Orlando HInajosa (1)
dietitian (1)
MPP Infusion (10)
exercise (1)
Flower Mound (2)
New Jerse (1)
National Nutrition Month (1)
#GoRed (2)
Infusion Center of Denver (4)
Saint Barnabas Medical Center (1)
Carrollton (1)
home dialysis (1)
the Action Center (1)
State Legislature (1)
Fitbit (1)
Go Red for Women (5)

Tag Cloud

New JerseSoutheast floodingDo's and Don'ts when interviewingCRNIBioMedTexas Renal VenturesSavor the Flavor of Eating RightBonfils blood donationacute nurseFive Star ratingNaveena ReddDOPPSNKFJCAHO accreditationDenton police departmentAccel Rehab hospitalflu vaccineSouthlake, TXCenters for Medicare and Medicaid ServicesFitbit10th anniversaryRenal Center of HamiltonANNA conferenceMother's DayInternbubble soccerWalk to Cure ArthritisNephrology NewsRenal Center of MorristownCMSNKF walkKidney Life Dialysis CenterStrokeDr. Stuart KassanDaVitaHeart DiseaseANNAPatient Satisfaction Surveyexercisedialysis treatmentAmerican Heart AssociationElanderia RoweRenal Center of PassaicProteinFitibtkidney disease exercisehome hemodialysisTake Your Dog to Work DayRedesign American FlagCouncil of Nephrology Social WorkersRV KidneyCAREMichelle Weinraubtraveling on dialysisThe HillsZ ConstructorsNederlandwrestlingrecipecookbookRV CARENew York YankeesSaint Barnabas Medical CenterKidney cookbookOrangePioneer awardRVCaretravelHuman ResourcesWorld Kidney DayapheresisHome Kidney Careplasmapheresisimmunizationpermanent accessback to schoolFrosty the SnowmanPlanoNRAAMary BowlesRASKAL awardPort Arthurgum diseaseArthritis Foundationoral hygieneCertified Registered Nurse Infusiongraduatesremote patient monitoringtelehealth servicesCMS rating systemRugged Maniacdialysis patient exerciseDaVita Healthcare partnersDr. ParkerRV Quality ProgramnephronAvalon at EdgewaterDr. AronoffInternshipBest Place to WorkRenal Center of TrentonRenal Center of Orangemiss dialysiswork anniversaryInfusion Center of Denverthe Action CenterretirementInformative InfuserhalitosisBone and Joint ExpoNaveena ReddyDiane McGinnisconstructionCarrolltonDum DumsSocial Workerdental careDallasExcellence awardperitoneal dialysisdialysispot de cremeInterviewInfusionRV TLCPinterestKidney walkGlass of waterChildren's HospitalAmerican College of Rheumatologydialysis centerdietitianNational MS Societyacute dialysisToledo Bend ReservoirrheumatologyInfusion nurseRV DifferenceJavier Rodriguezsmoke alarmRenal Center of SomervilleDigna GutierrezNorth DentonRenal Center of CarrolltonFire Prevention WeekTuition reimbursementMPP InfusionChoose My Platecupcakepatient newsletterTracy MooreAuthentidateflu shotLobby DaySpring Clinical MeetingState LegislatureRenal Center of Port ArthurQIRN3meningiomaRVM Kidney CareNew JerseyWorld Kidney MonthRVMLifeWinter Storm JonasWest VirginiaFlower MoundNational Kidney Monthdogs40th anniversaryAmerican Diabetes AssociationPaulding Phelps AwardRenal Center of SuccasunnaRV WellnessvideoSpirit AwardOrange, TXCosta VidaNorth Texas AcuteEmployee Appreciationopen houseGo Red for WomenAmerican Society of NephrologySouthlake InfusionPositively ProteinDr. George AronoffWorld Health DayRenal Center of North DentonMultiple Sclerosis SocietyNational Nutrition MonthKidney WeekYear in ReviewRenal AdventuresRenal Center of BeaumontOfficer Orlando HInajosahome dialysisAmerican Nephrology Nurses' AssociationRenal Center of Bayonnenew dialysis facilityPinnacle awardCitizenship DayKindergartenacquisitionRenal Center of PlanoBlizzard 2016National Kidney FoundationNew OrleansAnnual Dialysis Conference#GoRed


Aronoff's Point Of View: CMS rating system is flawed

Feb 05, 2015

Dr.-George-Aronoff.jpgThis month the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) added a Five-Star Quality Rating System to the Medicare Dialysis Facility Compare (DFC) website. The new rating system has been severely criticized by dialysis providers and patient advocacy groups. DFC was originally launched in 2001 to help consumers, their families, and caregivers compare dialysis units more easily. DFC provides general information about dialysis clinics, best clinical practices, hospitalizations and deaths. Unfortunately, DFC has not been as useful as it was originally hoped. Studies of DFC indicate that many patients and their families find it difficult to understand the descriptions of quality measures on the main web pages. I have been told that the DFC website is accessed more often by dialysis providers than dialysis patients.

Developing a five-star rating system to help Medicare beneficiaries make more informed choices about their dialysis care is a good idea. Many of us use similar ratings to choose restaurants, hotels, and even consumer products. Rating systems provide useful information when they accurately report information about those factors that are most important to our decisions about a product. For example, we expect that a five-star restaurant would have food that tastes better than a three-star restaurant and that the service at a five-star restaurant would be excellent.

Major criticisms of CMS's five-star dialysis unit rating system focus on whether CMS is accurately measuring factors that are important to dialysis patients and reporting them fairly. CMS has chosen to use data that were collected for far different purposes than to compare the quality of care among dialysis clinics. Many of these measures have little impact on patients' lives or their experience of care in a dialysis clinic. In addition, CMS has used very complicated methods to analyze the information making it almost impossible for individual clinics or patients to understand that there may be no real difference between a three-star dialysis unit and a five-star dialysis unit or even a one-star unit. Similar criticism has been leveled at other CMS five-star rating systems and has limited their usefulness to beneficiaries.

With all these flaws, I would still congratulate five-star units. They probably are doing something right. At the same time, I would encourage one- and two-star units to try to understand how the data that CMS used might have fallen short and how they might improve their patients' care and dialysis experience. A dialysis unit rating system could be helpful to our patients and their families. It is disappointing that CMS didn't take the opportunity to get this right.

Dr. George Aronoff is the Chief Medical Officer at Renal Ventures Management.  Dr. Aronoff comes from the University of Louisville School of Medicine, where he served as the Chief of the Nephrology Division for 23 years and as the Vice Chair of Medicine for Clinical Affairs. He currently holds the position of Professor of Medicine and Pharmacology there. Dr. Aronoff has 30 years of experience in designing and performing clinical research in hemodialysis, peritoneal dialysis, transplant and CKD patients.

- Read Dr. Aronoff's thoughts about how the CMS rating system can be improved

Category: Blogs