Your health and well-being are our top priority…

facebook.png twitter.png linkedin.png pinterest.png youtube.png Instagram.png

Aronoff's Point Of View: CMS rating system is flawed

Category List

Tag List

Renal Center of Hamilton (3)
dialysis (2)
DaVita Healthcare partners (1)
patient newsletter (3)
Dr. Parker (1)
Renal Center of Beaumont (1)
Officer Orlando HInajosa (1)
ANNA (1)
acute dialysis (1)
pot de creme (1)
Renal Center of Passaic (1)
Diane McGinnis (1)
Authentidate (2)
open house (2)
Nederland (1)
nephron (1)
Renal Center of Morristown (1)
Flower Mound (2)
DaVita (2)
Mother's Day (1)
New Jerse (1)
work anniversary (1)
rheumatology (1)
oral hygiene (1)
American College of Rheumatology (1)
Carrollton (1)
CRNI (1)
Social Worker (1)
North Texas Acute (1)
Best Place to Work (3)
American Diabetes Association (1)
flu shot (4)
Tuition reimbursement (3)
new dialysis facility (1)
Dr. Stuart Kassan (1)
National MS Society (1)
Accel Rehab hospital (1)
NKF (2)
the Action Center (1)
Certified Registered Nurse Infusion (1)
RVMLife (1)
Lobby Day (1)
wrestling (1)
Annual Dialysis Conference (1)
Dr. George Aronoff (4)
bubble soccer (1)
Positively Protein (3)
Pinnacle award (1)
Texas Renal Ventures (2)
telehealth services (1)
10th anniversary (3)
Do's and Don'ts when interviewing (1)
North Denton (1)
kidney disease exercise (1)
acquisition (1)
dental care (1)
World Health Day (1)
Nephrology News (4)
BioMed (1)
video (1)
Plano (1)
Infusion (6)
traveling on dialysis (1)
American Nephrology Nurses' Association (1)
peritoneal dialysis (3)
Frosty the Snowman (1)
Glass of water (1)
Z Constructors (1)
Blizzard 2016 (1)
Orange (1)
remote patient monitoring (2)
retirement (1)
RV Wellness (4)
Informative Infuser (1)
Take Your Dog to Work Day (1)
RV TLC (1)
Southlake Infusion (1)
Spirit Award (1)
Arthritis Foundation (2)
Pinterest (1)
Southlake, TX (1)
Naveena Redd (2)
Kidney walk (1)
immunization (2)
RVM Kidney Care (1)
Council of Nephrology Social Workers (1)
Kidney Week (1)
dialysis patient exercise (1)
Avalon at Edgewater (1)
Rugged Maniac (1)
Elanderia Rowe (1)
Renal Center of Port Arthur (1)
home dialysis (1)
Pioneer award (1)
Human Resources (1)
Winter Storm Jonas (1)
meningioma (1)
halitosis (1)
#GoRed (2)
Year in Review (5)
flu vaccine (3)
State Legislature (1)
RVCare (4)
Spring Clinical Meeting (1)
plasmapheresis (1)
Renal Center of Carrollton (1)
Kindergarten (1)
Go Red for Women (5)
cupcake (1)
National Kidney Foundation (5)
Orange, TX (1)
New Orleans (1)
Michelle Weinraub (1)
National Nutrition Month (1)
Bone and Joint Expo (1)
Savor the Flavor of Eating Right (1)
miss dialysis (2)
Kidney Life Dialysis Center (1)
Fitbit (1)
Renal Center of Plano (2)
Saint Barnabas Medical Center (1)
Costa Vida (1)
Port Arthur (1)
Fire Prevention Week (1)
American Heart Association (6)
Infusion nurse (2)
Southeast flooding (1)
gum disease (1)
Renal Center of Trenton (1)
Redesign American Flag (1)
New York Yankees (1)
Heart Disease (2)
smoke alarm (1)
Javier Rodriguez (1)
back to school (1)
National Kidney Month (2)
Excellence award (1)
dialysis treatment (2)
Internship (3)
Dum Dums (1)
Multiple Sclerosis Society (1)
Bonfils blood donation (2)
The Hills (1)
Home Kidney Care (2)
permanent access (1)
JCAHO accreditation (1)
New Jersey (6)
Renal Center of North Denton (1)
dietitian (1)
Dallas (1)
dialysis center (1)
Mary Bowles (1)
QIRN3 (1)
CMS rating system (3)
40th anniversary (1)
NRAA (2)
Tracy Moore (1)
Children's Hospital (1)
Dr. Aronoff (3)
recipe (2)
Employee Appreciation (1)
World Kidney Day (7)
Interview (1)
Walk to Cure Arthritis (1)
Choose My Plate (1)
RV Quality Program (3)
Renal Center of Succasunna (1)
ANNA conference (1)
graduates (1)
Renal Center of Orange (1)
Renal Adventures (2)
Fitibt (1)
Naveena Reddy (1)
Paulding Phelps Award (1)
Kidney cookbook (1)
Intern (3)
CMS (2)
NKF walk (2)
Citizenship Day (3)
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (1)
apheresis (1)
cookbook (2)
West Virginia (1)
Infusion Center of Denver (4)
Protein (2)
Renal Center of Bayonne (1)
World Kidney Month (4)
Denton police department (1)
travel (1)
RASKAL award (3)
Toledo Bend Reservoir (1)
acute nurse (1)
RV KidneyCARE (2)
Five Star rating (1)
MPP Infusion (10)
home hemodialysis (1)
Patient Satisfaction Survey (1)
exercise (1)
construction (2)
RV Difference (8)
Renal Center of Somerville (3)
dogs (1)
American Society of Nephrology (1)
Digna Gutierrez (1)
Stroke (2)

Tag Cloud

Dr. George AronoffWalk to Cure ArthritisAmerican Diabetes AssociationProteinOfficer Orlando HInajosaCertified Registered Nurse InfusionInternMichelle WeinraubStrokeRenal Center of TrentonRenal Center of North DentonacquisitionAmerican College of RheumatologyRugged ManiacBonfils blood donationRV KidneyCAREretirementNorth Texas AcuteplasmapheresisnephronWorld Health DayToledo Bend ReservoirDaVitaNRAAANNAWest VirginiaKidney Weekdialysis patient exerciseRV DifferenceRV WellnessgraduatesPaulding Phelps AwardTake Your Dog to Work Daydogs#GoRedCarrolltoncookbookDiane McGinnisKidney Life Dialysis CenterRV Quality Programsmoke alarmwork anniversaryEmployee AppreciationRenal Center of SomervilleQIRN3kidney disease exercisepot de cremeMPP InfusionWorld Kidney MonthNew York YankeesElanderia RowedietitianKindergartenZ Constructorstelehealth servicesInfusion nurseRedesign American Flagthe Action CenterTuition reimbursementNew JerseDaVita Healthcare partnersGo Red for WomenBlizzard 2016acute dialysisback to schoolAnnual Dialysis ConferenceCenters for Medicare and Medicaid ServicesInterviewAuthentidateKidney walkDOPPSperitoneal dialysis40th anniversaryMultiple Sclerosis SocietyhalitosisExcellence awardNew JerseySocial WorkerAmerican Heart AssociationDr. ParkerSaint Barnabas Medical CenterCMSRVCarepermanent accessRVM Kidney CarePositively ProteinTracy MoorerheumatologyRV TLCcupcakebubble soccerState LegislatureRenal AdventuresDr. AronoffCRNIflu vaccineexerciseAccel Rehab hospitalAmerican Nephrology Nurses' Associationopen houseDigna GutierrezDenton police departmentBest Place to WorkKidney cookbookvideoSpring Clinical MeetingFire Prevention WeekrecipeNKF walkacute nursetravelNaveena ReddSoutheast floodingNational Nutrition MonthWinter Storm JonasFitbitmiss dialysisMary BowlesAvalon at EdgewaterTexas Renal VenturesNederlandRenal Center of BayonneRVMLifeNorth DentonDo's and Don'ts when interviewingInfusionNational Kidney MonthSouthlake InfusionSpirit AwardimmunizationInternshipRenal Center of MorristownMother's DaySavor the Flavor of Eating RightNaveena ReddyNKFNational Kidney FoundationRenal Center of Port ArthurJavier RodriguezChoose My PlateDum Dumsgum diseasePlanoHeart DiseaseHome Kidney CareYear in Reviewflu shotNephrology NewsRenal Center of PlanoCMS rating systemFitibtPort ArthurCitizenship DayFrosty the SnowmanNational MS SocietyRenal Center of BeaumontInformative InfuserOrange, TXSouthlake, TXremote patient monitoringDallasPinterestBioMedDr. Stuart KassanFive Star ratingInfusion Center of DenverRenal Center of Carrollton10th anniversarynew dialysis facilityRV CAREdental careconstructionHuman ResourcesRASKAL awardFlower MounddialysisCosta VidaThe Hillshome hemodialysistraveling on dialysisWorld Kidney Dayoral hygieneRenal Center of OrangeANNA conferenceRenal Center of PassaicRenal Center of SuccasunnameningiomaBone and Joint ExpoRenal Center of HamiltonapheresisChildren's Hospitaldialysis centerJCAHO accreditationhome dialysisNew OrleansPatient Satisfaction SurveyPinnacle awardpatient newsletterAmerican Society of Nephrologydialysis treatmentLobby DayCouncil of Nephrology Social WorkersOrangeArthritis FoundationwrestlingPioneer awardGlass of water


Aronoff's Point Of View: CMS rating system is flawed

Feb 05, 2015

Dr.-George-Aronoff.jpgThis month the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) added a Five-Star Quality Rating System to the Medicare Dialysis Facility Compare (DFC) website. The new rating system has been severely criticized by dialysis providers and patient advocacy groups. DFC was originally launched in 2001 to help consumers, their families, and caregivers compare dialysis units more easily. DFC provides general information about dialysis clinics, best clinical practices, hospitalizations and deaths. Unfortunately, DFC has not been as useful as it was originally hoped. Studies of DFC indicate that many patients and their families find it difficult to understand the descriptions of quality measures on the main web pages. I have been told that the DFC website is accessed more often by dialysis providers than dialysis patients.

Developing a five-star rating system to help Medicare beneficiaries make more informed choices about their dialysis care is a good idea. Many of us use similar ratings to choose restaurants, hotels, and even consumer products. Rating systems provide useful information when they accurately report information about those factors that are most important to our decisions about a product. For example, we expect that a five-star restaurant would have food that tastes better than a three-star restaurant and that the service at a five-star restaurant would be excellent.

Major criticisms of CMS's five-star dialysis unit rating system focus on whether CMS is accurately measuring factors that are important to dialysis patients and reporting them fairly. CMS has chosen to use data that were collected for far different purposes than to compare the quality of care among dialysis clinics. Many of these measures have little impact on patients' lives or their experience of care in a dialysis clinic. In addition, CMS has used very complicated methods to analyze the information making it almost impossible for individual clinics or patients to understand that there may be no real difference between a three-star dialysis unit and a five-star dialysis unit or even a one-star unit. Similar criticism has been leveled at other CMS five-star rating systems and has limited their usefulness to beneficiaries.

With all these flaws, I would still congratulate five-star units. They probably are doing something right. At the same time, I would encourage one- and two-star units to try to understand how the data that CMS used might have fallen short and how they might improve their patients' care and dialysis experience. A dialysis unit rating system could be helpful to our patients and their families. It is disappointing that CMS didn't take the opportunity to get this right.

Dr. George Aronoff is the Chief Medical Officer at Renal Ventures Management.  Dr. Aronoff comes from the University of Louisville School of Medicine, where he served as the Chief of the Nephrology Division for 23 years and as the Vice Chair of Medicine for Clinical Affairs. He currently holds the position of Professor of Medicine and Pharmacology there. Dr. Aronoff has 30 years of experience in designing and performing clinical research in hemodialysis, peritoneal dialysis, transplant and CKD patients.

- Read Dr. Aronoff's thoughts about how the CMS rating system can be improved

Category: Blogs